Rust out vs. burnout: Understanding the key differences and how to address both

A Guide for Business Leaders By Charlene Gisele, Clinical Hypnotherapist and Burnout Advisor

Hi, I'm Charlene

Let’s talk about how to boost your performance and well-being.

London-based Charlène Gisèle is a distinguished Business & Performance Coach and Clinical Hypnotherapist renowned for her expertise in burnout prevention and sustainable high performance.

A former lawyer, her unique approach empowers high-achieving professionals to optimise their careers without compromising their well-being. This year the buzzword in HR and business is burnout.

As the pressures of modern professional life continue to escalate, burnout has become a widely recognised term, particularly in workplaces where high performance is expected.

The issue of burnout is increasingly visible, especially with rising mental health-related sickness rates. In the UK, for instance, mental health issues were identified as contributing to four of the top causes of long-term sick leave in 2023, with stress, anxiety, and depression being leading factors (Health and Safety Executive, 2023).

However, burnout is not the only stress-related condition employees face. An equally significant yet often overlooked phenomenon is “rust out.” Recognising the differences between these two conditions is crucial for leaders and organisations aiming to create a supportive and effective work environment.

The term “rust out” was coined by psychotherapist Paula Coles in 2019 to describe the phenomenon where employees experience disengagement and boredom due to a lack of challenge and stimulation in their work. Unlike burnout, which stems from overwhelming demands and high stress, rust out occurs when employees face a monotonous and uninspiring work environment that fails to stretch their abilities.

This sense of stagnation can lead to feelings of alienation, disengagement, and ultimately a decrease in job satisfaction. Employees suffering from rust out may feel underutilised, which can be just as detrimental to their mental health and productivity as burnout. As noted by Coles, rust out can cause employees to become “apathetic and alienated,” significantly affecting their overall performance and wellbeing.

Although burnout and rust out arise from different causes, they share several overlapping symptoms, primarily because both are forms of stress that affect both mental and physical health. Psychologically, employees suffering from burnout or rust out may exhibit irritability, emotional outbursts, or tearfulness.

Socially, they may withdraw from colleagues, avoid social events, or, conversely, overindulge in social interactions in a manner that deviates from their usual behaviour. Biologically, both conditions can lead to an increased susceptibility to illness due to a suppressed immune system, often exacerbated by chronic stress. Additionally, both burnout and rust out may manifest in practical ways, such as a decline in the quality of work, missed deadlines, or a decrease in enthusiasm for tasks that once motivated the individual.

The consequences of both burnout and rust out can be profound. Affected employees may take increased sick leave, reduce their work effort, or, in more severe cases, resort to “quiet quitting,” where they only meet the bare minimum expectations of their roles. Leaders must be especially aware of the risk of high-performing employees seeking new opportunities, as top talent is often the first to leave when they feel disengaged or unsupported.

According to a Gallup report (2022), employees who are not adequately challenged are 2.5 times more likely to quit within a year compared to those who feel stimulated and engaged by their work. Addressing these issues promptly is critical for retaining skilled professionals and maintaining an efficient workforce.

The fundamental difference in addressing burnout versus rust out lies in how these conditions are managed. With burnout, the focus is on reducing stress by managing workloads, improving work-life balance, providing emotional support, and fostering resilience. In contrast, rust out requires a different approach, one that focuses on re-engaging and inspiring employees by offering meaningful challenges that align with their strengths and interests. Leaders need to recognise that while both conditions are damaging, the interventions for each are distinct.

For burnout, it is essential to encourage employees to set clear boundaries and avoid overcommitting. One of the most effective ways to help employees manage workload stress is to empower them to say “no” without guilt or explanation. Setting boundaries can be particularly important for employees who have a tendency to overextend themselves due to a desire to please others.

Providing them with the language to manage such requests, such as saying, “Let me check my schedule” or “I’ll get back to you,” can allow them the time to evaluate their priorities before committing. Additionally, limiting the amount of time spent on tasks, offering alternatives (“I can’t, but X can”), and asking, “What will be most helpful to you?” can also help employees maintain control over their workloads and reduce the risk of burnout.

When it comes to rust out, the focus shifts to identifying and leveraging employees’ strengths. Professionals are often promoted based on their skills, but over time, they may find themselves in roles that no longer align with their true passions or strengths. As Coles points out, when employees are not challenged in ways that engage their core strengths, they may begin to feel unfulfilled.

A key strategy for addressing rust out is to engage employees in a conversation about their strengths and how those can be applied to more stimulating and rewarding tasks. It is important to distinguish between skills, which are competencies that can be learned, and strengths, which are inherent qualities that energize individuals and make them feel fulfilled. Encouraging employees to identify what they enjoy and what sparks enthusiasm, rather than just what they are good at, can be a critical step in re-engaging them.

Leaders must also recognise that addressing either burnout or rust out requires more than simply implementing one-size-fits-all wellness programs. Rather, organisations should engage with their teams to determine the conditions that allow them to thrive. By understanding what motivates employees and what support they need during difficult times, leaders can create tailored strategies that promote a healthier, more productive work environment.

Research has shown that personalised wellbeing initiatives are significantly more effective in improving employee engagement and reducing turnover rates than generic programs (Corporate Leadership Council, 2022).

Ultimately, whether dealing with burnout or rust out, the key to a successful approach lies in understanding the underlying causes of stress and responding with targeted, individualised solutions. Both conditions require leaders to foster an environment where employees feel challenged, supported, and equipped to thrive.

By addressing the unique needs of each individual, organisations can create a more resilient, engaged workforce that not only avoids burnout and also prevents the disengagement associated with rust out.

As published in www.londonworld.com

Scroll to Top

Something feels off… but you can’t quite name it.

Before you go Take my free 3-minute burnout quiz and get clarity now!